G. A. L. E. S. L.
  • Home
  • Blog
  • ESL Links
    • Links during Online Classes
    • General English
    • TOEIC
    • TOEFL
    • Online Conversation / Language Exchange
    • Listening
    • Vocabulary
    • Grammar
    • Verbs
    • Business English
    • Telephone English
    • Other Links
  • Articles
    • Q & A: Help with International Accents, Page 1 >
      • Accents page 2: Ask them to slow down
      • Accents page 3: Get to know other accents
      • Accents page 4: Using online accent resources: IDEA
      • Accents page 5: Using online accent resources: Speech Accent Archive
      • Accents page 6: Using online accent resources: Map Your Voice
    • Case Study: BMW and Rover
  • Conversation Issues
    • Nice to meet you
    • How have you been?
    • Where are you? / Where are you from?
    • meet a problem
    • colleagues
    • -ed [versus] -ing
    • borrow [versus] lend
    • "or" questions
    • Relax myself
    • Sorry for my late
    • Name card
  • Search
  • About / Contact
  • Sound Problems
    • Feedback & Echo
    • No Sound
    • Fans
    • Interruptions
    • Volume Level

Q&A: Several ways to ask a question

26/10/2012

0 Comments

 
My Hiknow student C.C. asks:
Hi Joe,
I have a doubt about the question:
  • What are characteristics a person needs to start and run a business?
This sentence is from the phrasal verb lesson "Business - starting and doing business".
I'm not sure of the grammar here, because I would ask:
  • What characteristics does a person need to start and run a business?
I mean I would change the "are" to "does". I don't know if I'm right or not.
Best regards
My answer:
Your sentence is correct. And so is the other one. They're both right, just different structures.
I believe the grammar of the questions might become clearer if I give you not only a grammatical explanation of the questions, but also example answers to the questions in the form of complete sentences.
I'll use a colour code to help demonstrate the grammar.
  • Bold red = subject of sentence
  • Bold green = main verb of sentence
  • Bold purple = direct object or predicate of main verb
  • Pink = indirect object of the main verb
  • Gold = a clause or phrase that gives more information about another part of the sentence
1.
  • What are characteristics [that] a person needs to start and run a business?
  • Passion and intelligence are characteristics [that] a person needs to start a business.
2.
  • What characteristics does a person need to start and run a business?
  • A person needs passion and intelligence to start and run a business.
In Question 1:
  •  "what" is the subject
  •  "are" is the verb
  •  "characteristics" is the predicate of the verb "are"
  • "a person needs to start and run a business" is a defining relative clause about "characteristics"
The defining relative clause (more info) makes the question not about all characteristics that exist in the universe, but only about ones needed to start a business. This defining clause could start with "that..." but you don't have to have it.
In Answer 1,
  •  "Passion and intelligence" is the subject
  •  "are" is the verb
  •  "characteristics" is the predicate of the verb "are"
  •  "a person needs to start and run a business" is a defining clause about "characteristics"
In Question 2:
  •  "a person" is the subject
  •  "does... need" is the verb
  •  "what characteristics" is the object of the verb "does... need"
  •  "to start and run a business" is an infinitive phrase that is the indirect object of the verb "does... need"
Infinitive phrases (more info) can be used many ways. Here it's the indirect object of "does... need".
In Answer 2:
  •  "a person" is the subject
  •  "needs" is the verb
  •  "passion and intelligence" are the object of the verb "needs"
  •  "to start and run a business" is an infinitive phrase that is the indirect object of the verb "needs"
I'll also give a third possibility :D
3.
  • What are characteristics needed to start and run a business?
  • Passion and intelligence are characteristics needed to start a business.
In Question 3:
  •  "what" is the subject
  •  "are" is the verb
  •  "characteristics" is the predicate of the verb "are"
  •  "needed to start and run a business" is a past participle clause describing "characteristics"
Participle clauses (more info), using either past participle (usually -ed) or present participle/gerund (-ing), are similar to relative clauses, giving more info about another word in the sentence.
In Answer 3:
  •  "Passion and intelligence" is the subject
  •  "are" is the verb
  •  "characteristics" is the predicate of the verb "are"
  •  "needed to start and run a business" is a past participle clause describing "characteristics"
Oh boy, I just though of a fourth way!
4.
  • What characteristics are needed to start and run a business?
  • Passion and intelligence are needed to start a business.
In Question 4:
  •  "what characteristics" is the subject
  •  "are needed" is the verb, in passive voice
  •  "to start and run a business" is an infinitive phrase that is the indirect object of the verb "are needed"
In passive voice (more info), the subject receives the verb, so there is no direct object.
In Answer 4:
  •  "Passion and intelligence" is the subject
  •  "are needed" is the verb, in passive voice
  •  "to start and run a business" is an infinitive phrase that is the indirect object of the verb "are needed"
So you see, there's more than one way to ask a question! I hope that makes clearer for you these different possibilities.
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    G.A.L.E.S.L. / joe3

    Some tips and links on learning English.

    RSS Feed

    Picture
    My microblog on
    ​Hiknow English

    Categories

    All
    About This Site
    Accent
    Adjectives
    Advertising
    Alcohol
    Attraction
    Audio
    Beauty
    Blogging
    Books
    Building
    Business
    Career
    China
    City
    Class Time
    Cloud Computing
    Coaching
    Communication
    Complaints
    Computing
    Conflict
    Conversation Issues
    Culture
    Customer Service
    CV/resume
    Diacritics
    E Commerce
    E-commerce
    Education
    Electrical Engineering
    E Mail
    E-mail
    Emailec5f5ec77c
    Emphasis
    Employment
    Engagement
    Engineering
    English Variations
    Entertaining
    Environment
    Ethics
    Exercise
    Finance
    Food
    Funny
    Grammar
    Health
    Home
    House
    Human Resources
    Idioms
    Images
    Induction
    Internet
    Interview
    Job Hunting
    Language Exchange
    Leadership
    Links
    Listening
    Marketing
    Marriage
    Measurement
    Meetings
    Mentoring
    Microblogging
    Mistakes
    Mobile Phones
    Money
    Movies
    Negotiation
    Numbers
    Office
    Phrasal Verbs
    Presentation
    Productivity
    Professional Development
    Project Management
    Pronunciation
    Q&A
    Qualifications
    Questions
    Recruitment
    Sales
    Social Networking
    Software
    Sport
    Suburb
    Telephone
    Telephone English
    The West
    Time
    Tips
    Tone
    Training
    Travel
    Tv
    Uk
    University
    Us
    Verbs
    Video
    Visuals
    Vocab
    Vocabulary
    Weather
    Web Hosts
    Weddings
    Work
    Writing

    Archives

    June 2017
    December 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    August 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011
    November 2010
    October 2010
    September 2010
    August 2010
    July 2010

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
Photo used under Creative Commons from roland
  • Home
  • Blog
  • ESL Links
    • Links during Online Classes
    • General English
    • TOEIC
    • TOEFL
    • Online Conversation / Language Exchange
    • Listening
    • Vocabulary
    • Grammar
    • Verbs
    • Business English
    • Telephone English
    • Other Links
  • Articles
    • Q & A: Help with International Accents, Page 1 >
      • Accents page 2: Ask them to slow down
      • Accents page 3: Get to know other accents
      • Accents page 4: Using online accent resources: IDEA
      • Accents page 5: Using online accent resources: Speech Accent Archive
      • Accents page 6: Using online accent resources: Map Your Voice
    • Case Study: BMW and Rover
  • Conversation Issues
    • Nice to meet you
    • How have you been?
    • Where are you? / Where are you from?
    • meet a problem
    • colleagues
    • -ed [versus] -ing
    • borrow [versus] lend
    • "or" questions
    • Relax myself
    • Sorry for my late
    • Name card
  • Search
  • About / Contact
  • Sound Problems
    • Feedback & Echo
    • No Sound
    • Fans
    • Interruptions
    • Volume Level